Is it just me or does it seem like anytime something fun is released, someone somewhere in the world gets their panties in a bunch over it? Spore is no exception. Creationists are outraged at the title for what they claim is "Propaganda." some Creationist groups are even lobbying for a ban, claiming:

"this entire game is propaganda aimed directly at our children to teach them evolution instead of creationism."

Funny enough, the game actually resembles the Creationist model of existence far more than Darwinist Evolution. The mere fact that you can have one specific race of creature and, in a single generation, evolve into something that looks nothing like the first model does not suggest a gradual evolution based on the survival of the species (at least, they didn't survive any better... still getting owned in the field... grumble grumble). In fact, it no more promotes Darwin's theories on Evolution than Pokemon does.

Instead, the game functions through an omnipotent being (you the player) making instant changes to the world and your creatures. As anyone knows, evolution involves millions of years and slow, gradual changes. While Spore would be a boring game had it taken the evolution too realistically, it hardly serves as mirrior for Neo-Darwinism.

Your thoughts?

AMENDMENT: Reader JoeSFO, in his ever vigilant watch to help keep gamegirl.com the best it can possibly be, has alerted me to the fact that this was, indeed, a hoax site I sourced from. As I mentioned in the comment section, this was written before truth was admitted on the part of the authors. Although this particular comedy/tragedy of a situation fell through, I am sure others can appreciate that this kind of fervor occurs anytime anything is released that challenges the views of the people. This goes for creationism and neo darwinism alike. Thus has not lacked complete applicability.

I feel like Oprah apologizing for the book, "A Thousand Little Pieces" now ^_^

Comments [38]

post a comment

MrGregs

I do feel like I have to intelligently design my creature. I like that look at it. Then again changing it is called evolution.

Side note if being hungry and eating made me have a larger brain I too would have a tribal fake mustach (one can dream).

Zumbikilla

"this entire game is propaganda aimed directly at our children to teach them evolution instead of creationism."

LOL, it's so funny, for that people the conspiracy theory is just a fact, someone is watching us!!!!!!

So, they think a videogame should educate their children instead of family, school and other institutions, amazing.

trueheart78

Uninformed people will always make harsh accusations. It is a parent's responsibility to investigate as well as allow/deny anything their children might want.

greensabre

Well it took longer than I expected to hear this argument... Anyways, it's a FANTASY game. Just look at it. I didn't hear PETA complaining that Super Mario Bros. is cruel to animals because you jump on turtles. I haven't played the game so I don't really know all the details (and I bet many of the creationists, who are the real propagandists, haven't played it either) but what Navie is describing is absolutely NOT Darwin's Theory of Evolution. If you don't want your kids playing it, that's fine, don't buy it. But don't go all Third Reich on it because it doesn't mesh with YOUR religious faith. BTW I'm both a Christian and a Biologist (yes the two can coexist.) Sorry about the wall of text, believe me I'm holding back here.

greensabre

^^Just to clarify what I said, I'm talking about the creationists who want to ban Spore, not creationists in general. I'm not trying to start a faith war here.

Navie

I agree greensabre. I myself am Christian and also scientifically minded (Considering teaching physics for a career) and both can exist together.

and hell, its a damned game lol!

Be sure to be on the look out for a group Game Girl review of this game in the future btw!

greensabre

^^Cool, I'm looking forward to that review and a computer that can actually run the game lol. I almost got the Creature Creator for DS the other day, but it's probably way too watered-down. Good luck with physics (I couldn't take the calculus haha) Navie!!

Navie

Yeah I wouldn't really go with the DS version, go for the full monty pc version imo!

haha, Im not back to university yet, and it is only an option I am considering. Also, I happen to be considering teaching English Lit. Im sure I'd love either one.

Zumbikilla

It's not the theme here, but.... I would like to see a tales of vesperia review!!!!!! please? :P

Post a Comment