This week we take a some what more serious tone. The question this week is from Marcela Roberts:

What do you think about using video games to help with mental health?

Read on to see our answers


Marcela, I think using video games for health issues is a great idea. Gaming is already used as a way for people with disabilities to interact with others. It also can bring them a sense of accomplishment or achievement for beating the levels. It helps patients to lower their stress. Plus many older generation individuals use the Wii to help keep their mobility going. It gives them a easier way to stay mobile and exercise without the impact you would get from exercising from jumping, and other exercises.
Even though it doesn't effect everyone, it hits closer to home many times. Nobody expects to get sick, and I learned that first hand with my cousin a while back. My cousin had a spinal stroke at the age of 18, and now is in a wheel chair. He loves video games, and uses it as another way for him to interact with his friends. It has really helped him, due to he used to be very active in sports and other activities before he had the spinal stroke.
I know video games will not work for every case, but if it can help an individual to cope or even conquer their illness, then I feel it is a great asset to the health field. There is a group called the Games for Health, that has a convention to discuss and showcase ways to use video games to support health. One way is to use video games for rehab and therapy. They have created a version of Guitar Hero to help aid in arm amputee rehab, they have a Parkinson's Disease version of the Wii that is currently being developed to help PD patients with balance and mobility, and much more. These are just a few of the many ways that video games are being brought into the health field, and I am sure there will be many more to come.


I think it is ground best tread carefully upon. It's important we don't start marketing GTA4 and Super Smash Brothers as tools of healing for post-op brain surgery patients. However, it would be a worthwhile endeavor to use video game technology to create games suited to the purpose of strengthening hand/eye coordination, memory, and other brain function for patients who may have suffered an accident and lost those abilities. I think something like this would be beneficial for people who suffered head trauma and lost function they may have once had; but I would hazard a guess that, in the case of your blog example, it would do very little to help neuroses like OCD.


I am all about using video games to help anyone. Using anything for a positive purpose is always good. Although I do not believe something as simple as just a video game can help most metal illnesses, those issues are so much more deep rooted than that. But hey, if someone wants to try it and something positive can come out of it, then why not.


I am all for video games helping any kind of illness whether it is a mental or physical illness. One of my cousins has a muscular disease that pretty much makes his hands useless to him. My sister and I would always play video games with him whenever he wasn't going through his physical therapy. It helped him a lot because he needed to try and get some strength in his hands and sitting down gave his back and legs a break as well --he has to use a walker in order to actually be able to get anywhere around the house.
Video games are a great way of building hand-eye coordination and for a victim who went through anything that has traumatized their brain I think would help them out greatly. There are certain games that would be pointless to use for this --Grand Theft Auto or Military Games-- but then there are some awesome games that aren't as violent but can help out a lot --Spyro or Guitar Hero. Gaming is also a good way to pass the time for those that have to stay in the hospital for long periods of time because it gives them the opportunity to communicate with others and enjoy their time in the hospital when it would normally be a very boring stay.


Got a question of your own for the GameGirls? Send an email to them at Tips4GameGirl@gmail.com. Your question may appear in the next segment!

Comments [68]

post a comment

JoeSFO

I have a question: why does the ratio of PS3 to 360 coverage on this website suck so much? It even made me wonder if it means girl gamers don't play PS3's, but that's utterly ridiculous, given the PS2's userbase and wider selection of genres. That leaves me with two other theories.

I think maybe whoever's hiring the girls for this site gets them from the same place - apparently some Halo gaming competition or something - and that this site does not truly represent girl gamers at large and rather represents only a certain subgroup of girl gamers.

Alternatively, it could be that the more publicly-outed girl gamers feel added pressure to prove to others (i.e., the male gaming community) that they are "truleez realz hardkorz" gamers and are thus drawn to what's considered the more "hardcore" options: like Halo, the Xbox360 and the infantile denizens of Xbox Live. It's constantly Halo-this, Ninja-that, GearsofWar-other here...as if girl gamers looking to prove their gaming l33tness need to act like one of the guys...but I do not believe the greater part of the girl gaming audience (who are overwhelmingly in the "closet" gamer category) is really into those things.

Regardless, I think there is a huge disconnect between the portrayal of girl gaming on this website versus what it truly is in reality. I know this website bashes games like "Imagine: Babyz", probably because it's not "hardcore" enough and takes away gobs and gobs of street cred, but, in reality, it is consistently one of Amazon's bestsellers and consistently within their top 75. A good chunk of people is buying games like that. I'd like to think it's a ton of guys buying up "Imagine: Babyz" as part of an educational study on practicing safe sex, but I doubt that's really the case. Maybe instead of bashing games like "Imagine: Babyz" because they're not tomboy enough, games like those should be applauded for getting more girls into gaming at a younger age. More and more games are specifically targeting females, and that should be considered better than the alternative. Genders *are* different. If they're not, what's this website's raison d'etre? Right now, it's like you gals have had all your preferences defined for you by guy gamers and have nothing unique to say. It's like I'm reading guy-crap spit back at me. Are girl gamers really this..."un-girlish"? Obviously not.

So what do y'all think? (Sure, there's a little bit of hyperbole sprinkled in this post, here and there, but it's for emphasis.) Maybe it's just whoever's doing the hiring here that needs to be blamed.

JoeSFO

Lol, the banner ads I just got are for Castro GTX motor oil and the Proactiv acne ripoff (it's just regular benzoil peroxide). Even the advertisements can't figure out who this site is supposed to appeal to.

Navie

A few points here:

1. You're an idiot.

2. We aren't hired, this isn't a paid position and we have never been approached by anyone to only promote certain games

3. If you'd stop cock-jockeying Solid Snake long enough, you'd realize the ps3 has a small library of mediocre non exclusives coupled with an outrageous price tag. Maybe when Sony finally puts out some WORTHY games, it will get covered.

4. No one here feels like they need to prove to others their "leetness" and if you actually frequented the site longer than the five minutes it took to turn out this piece of ignorant garbage I'm sure you think is a witty commentary, you'd realize that. Alot of DS and casual games are covered on a regular basis.

5. I've never played Halo, or Ninja Gaidan LOL. My gamerscore for xbl is 475... OH NOES I AM NOT TEH LEET ENOUGH!!!!!1111oneoneeleven

6. Your poor attempt at being suave with your pseudo-french posh phrases makes me giggle. teehee.

7. Someone who actually takes the time to make a response like this probably doesn't know any girls in real life, therefore how can you even be "in the know" enough to compare us writers to what you call "actual girl gamers" hmm?

I find it amazing that it seems if you have a vagina and play games, you just can't win. Play World of Warcraft and you're an attention whore. Play only your Nintendo DS and suddenly you're not a real gamer. And now this: Cover games that people actually have an investment in and you're obviously just plain trying too hard.

I am detecting psychology 101 case here of "sour grapes."

_Mandy_

What an ironic offtopic response to an article about gaming and mental health. hummmm.

AlanaNight

Being a girl gamer myself, I have to say, I have a PS3 and 360, and I use my 360 and the Wii way more than the PS3. Don't get me wrong, it's a great system with really good features. But for the most part, there's no really great titles out on the PS3 that are ps3 EXCLUSIVE. Once there are more girls will take interest. But us girls, we're about quality. And right now 360 is winning.

As for games and mental health. I feel it's a given that games stimulate the mind. Look at Brain Age on the DS, which focuses on renewing the mind. As long as the games is geared towards mental stimulation it can be beneficial. If it's not the most you can get is good hand-eye coordination.

averagejoe131

Responses arent exactly related to the article.... But congrats to Navie for having a go at a nob-jockey.

Navie

I had about two paragraphs typed up, but I erased them in favor of simply saying you're a numpty, and not even worth my time.

hanras

[quote]I had about two paragraphs typed up, but I erased them in favor of simply saying you're a numpty, and not even worth my time.[/quote]

namecalling. mature.

Navie

Arguing on the internet about consoles is pointless, which is why i deleted what I typed. I could throw facts, figures, and testimonials from God himself at you and you would never change your mind so... pointless. Besides, I got my 360 elite for free, I have ten games for it... its ok aluru, we all make mistakes in judging people and what they are like. PC gaming rigs are by far better to game on than any console anyways. THERES a fact for you.

Oh geez, really? 5 GBP a month for xbl? How will I ever be able to afford it? Oh wait, that job thing I have.

Navie

Besides, my first comment was in regards to JoeSTO, not yourself. And it was about girl gamers, not console wars. You jumped in on one offhanded remark about the PS3 and got all bent out of shape, and are probably sitting there refreshing the page now as I type this... wtf is wrong with you? and you threw the term fangirl at me? Basically, you're whole arguement thus far boils down to you're allowed to have an opinion, and everyone else who thinks differently is wrong.

I don't know if the ps3 is any good, I've never played one. All I've done is looked at the games available for it and felt underwhelmed about ever owning one. The fact that you are ignorant enough to outright express this much hate towards someone over an opinion on a VIDEO GAME CONSOLE... Im at a sheer loss for words.

Post a Comment